Remove this ad
Author Comment

Replies

Bach Gigue #6 Question Aug 31 11 8:08 PM tehcellist
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Aug 31 11 9:39 PM TtheCellist
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 5:05 AM Bob
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 5:10 AM sarah schenkman
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 10:04 AM tedeum
   de gustibus! Sep 1 11 10:17 AM Bob
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 4:18 PM zambocello
      here we go . . . Sep 1 11 5:33 PM Bob
         Moderator!!!!! Sep 1 11 11:25 PM zambocello
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 7:26 AM cbrey
            wow! Sep 2 11 7:55 AM Bob
               Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 8:13 AM cbrey
                  Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 8:46 AM Bob
                     Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 4 11 5:15 PM cbrey
            Thanks, Carter Sep 2 11 10:59 AM zambocello
            Am I missing something? Sep 4 11 8:18 AM chiddler
         Could the argument have started here? Sep 26 11 12:38 PM LeMaster
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 5:01 PM etsisk
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 5:40 PM somicello
      lol! Sep 1 11 5:47 PM Bob
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 12:11 PM PatWhite
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 7:58 PM TtheCellist
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 8:27 PM SteveDrake4
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 9:31 PM mvotapek
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 1 11 10:20 PM tedeum
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 4:55 AM sarah schenkman
   Cello Chat at its best Sep 2 11 8:03 AM Josephinethecellist
      It was even better than that! Sep 2 11 9:29 AM LeMaster
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 5:11 PM etsisk
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 8:17 AM tehcellist
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 2 11 8:53 AM rovatti
   You flatter me, Tom! Sep 3 11 8:10 AM LeMaster
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 3 11 7:54 PM etsisk
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 3 11 6:32 PM Geemusic
      (ofraheavenssake) Sep 4 11 7:55 AM LeMaster
   Thank You, Larry Sep 3 11 6:58 PM Josephinethecellist
   expletive deleted Sep 4 11 11:00 AM Geemusic
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 5 11 1:11 AM Miffopro
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 5 11 11:14 AM tedeum
   . . . and so, in conclusion . . . Sep 6 11 3:11 PM Bob
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 6 11 5:10 PM cbrey
   Larry, put that stuff back in your post! Sep 6 11 3:25 PM Josephinethecellist
   And . . . Sep 6 11 3:32 PM Josephinethecellist
   Thank God that's settled. Sep 6 11 5:16 PM SteveDrake4
      DON JUAN Sep 7 11 10:21 AM LeMaster
   V is a dominant right? I only have a Juilliard education... Sep 7 11 12:35 AM BA
      {polishes fingernails on lapel} Sep 7 11 6:19 AM Bob
   No one got Bach's phone number..? Sep 7 11 6:54 AM Miffopro
   very interesting thread...thank you all for your thoughts and analysis'... Sep 7 11 2:30 PM berlincello
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 7 11 10:37 PM TtheCellist
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 11 11 7:30 AM cellomaestro
   post erased Sep 11 11 9:00 PM Geemusic
      wow squared!! Sep 12 11 4:55 AM Bob
      erased? Sep 13 11 8:29 AM SteveDrake4
         deletions Sep 13 11 9:12 AM Geemusic
            Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 13 11 9:31 AM SteveDrake4
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 13 11 10:54 AM karenlee
      re-post of first Levin analysis Sep 14 11 4:56 AM Geemusic
   Beyond the hallowed halls Sep 12 11 8:16 AM Josephinethecellist
      Josephine Sep 12 11 9:12 AM Geemusic
         Like! Sep 12 11 9:40 AM LeMaster
   Enough! Sep 12 11 12:00 PM Johann Sebastian Bach
   Thanks! And . . . The Dress???? Sep 12 11 12:43 PM Josephinethecellist
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 12 11 12:47 PM sarah schenkman
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 12 11 3:03 PM zambocello
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 12 11 3:09 PM ashcello93
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 12 11 4:49 PM rovatti
   Sticks and stones... Sep 13 11 9:39 AM cellistpilot
      ok - old and new analysis coming Sep 13 11 11:11 AM Geemusic
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 13 11 11:23 AM cellofan07
            Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 13 11 1:10 PM karenlee
            The next can of worms Sep 13 11 1:36 PM zambocello
            Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 13 11 1:40 PM somicello
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 13 11 2:44 PM LeMaster
   A request for understanding Sep 13 11 4:28 PM Geemusic
      (criminy!) Sep 14 11 10:25 AM LeMaster
         Criminy Grits Sep 14 11 10:47 AM Geemusic
         well, Larry... Sep 15 11 2:08 PM etsisk
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 13 11 6:28 PM rovatti
   Rovati Sep 13 11 6:47 PM Geemusic
   Leave ME the heck out of it!! Sep 13 11 8:32 PM etsisk
      okay Sep 13 11 9:04 PM SteveDrake4
         I'm awake Sep 14 11 7:27 AM Tim Janof
      Tom? Sep 15 11 4:30 PM LeMaster
         Can't we all just get along? Sep 15 11 4:56 PM ashcello93
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 15 11 10:55 PM etsisk
            Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 16 11 9:54 PM LeMaster
               Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 16 11 10:53 PM etsisk
   Levin Analysis Part II Sep 14 11 6:41 AM Geemusic
      Oh NO!!! Sep 14 11 11:25 AM Ellen Cello
         I'm afraid so, Ellen Sep 14 11 3:54 PM Geemusic
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 14 11 11:27 AM Josephinethecellist
   Josephine Sep 14 11 11:41 AM Geemusic
   Oh, I think I understand Sep 14 11 11:51 AM Geemusic
   OTOH, Geemusic, Sep 14 11 12:49 PM LeMaster
      Oops Sep 14 11 5:30 PM Geemusic
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 14 11 4:38 PM zambocello
      Thanks a pant-load, Z! Sep 14 11 5:38 PM LeMaster
         To add to his perfect world... Sep 14 11 6:49 PM ashcello93
   my swan song on this Sep 14 11 6:56 PM Bob
      Wow! Sep 14 11 7:39 PM Ellen Cello
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 14 11 8:04 PM cellistpilot
      Bob, Bob, Bob, Bob, Bob........... Sep 14 11 11:38 PM zambocello
      Just some thoughts Sep 15 11 6:06 AM Geemusic
         This entire dispute in one pithy statement Sep 15 11 6:25 AM Bob
            generalizations Sep 15 11 6:47 AM Geemusic
               LOL!! Sep 15 11 7:11 AM Bob
                  uh oh Bob Sep 15 11 2:04 PM Geemusic
            Umm... Sep 15 11 7:00 AM soccerandcello
               Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 15 11 7:56 AM cielocello
                  Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 15 11 8:43 AM rovatti
      Sorry Bob Sep 17 11 5:02 AM baroquecello
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 17 11 6:04 AM karenlee
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 17 11 12:05 PM ARBettridge
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 17 11 4:05 PM sarah schenkman
   bob, bob, Bob, Bob, BOB !!!! Sep 15 11 8:43 AM zambocello
      dearest Z, Sep 15 11 9:11 AM Bob
         And so forth Sep 15 11 1:30 PM zambocello
            and again . . . Sep 15 11 1:41 PM Bob
               I don't think so, Bob. The reams of analysis... Sep 15 11 3:17 PM zambocello
                  Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 15 11 6:55 PM mvotapek
                     Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 16 11 1:13 AM zambocello
                  Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 15 11 8:32 PM Bob
                     Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 16 11 5:49 AM karenlee
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 15 11 10:54 AM mvotapek
   Music theory or theology? Sep 15 11 11:35 AM cellistpilot
      pretty good thread, though Sep 15 11 2:36 PM Geemusic
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 16 11 12:45 PM jpclos
   Inductive reasoning Sep 16 11 6:07 PM johntramsay
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 17 11 2:06 PM jpclos
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 17 11 3:45 PM karenlee
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 17 11 7:06 PM schreechy
   2CELLOS Sep 17 11 10:11 PM ElyseHowdershell
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 18 11 12:20 AM jpclos
   Roundup Sep 23 11 2:59 PM Bob
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 24 11 4:35 AM cielocello
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 24 11 5:59 AM baroquecello
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 24 11 11:47 AM SteveDrake4
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 24 11 1:29 PM rovatti
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 24 11 10:43 PM zambocello
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 25 11 12:43 AM jpclos
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 25 11 11:56 AM baroquecello
      let's see! Sep 25 11 2:30 PM Bob
         Wait no longer! Sep 25 11 3:16 PM zambocello
            oh, "by implication"!!! Sep 25 11 3:29 PM Bob
               "by implication" Sep 25 11 4:07 PM zambocello
                  Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 25 11 4:48 PM Bob
                     who's grasping at straws? Sep 25 11 5:33 PM zambocello
                        you are!! Sep 25 11 6:00 PM Bob
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 25 11 4:07 PM ebenjen
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 25 11 4:01 PM ebenjen
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 26 11 7:25 AM cielocello
      there's some REAL analysis for ya! Sep 26 11 7:35 AM Bob
   In basic simple layman's terms Sep 26 11 8:29 AM cellistpilot
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 26 11 8:55 AM karenlee
      in even simpler terms Sep 26 11 8:59 AM Bob
   While we're at it.... Sep 26 11 8:56 AM klengelhasser
   Floggin a dead horse Sep 26 11 9:01 AM johntramsay
      indeed you are! Sep 26 11 9:08 AM Bob
   C#.....what about the recap? Sep 26 11 9:08 AM cellophile369
      would make just as much sense! Sep 26 11 9:11 AM Bob
         or St Elizabeth's Sep 26 11 9:47 AM rovatti
      I like certainty -- it's with reality that I have issues ;) Sep 26 11 4:22 PM zambocello
         apparently so! Sep 26 11 4:52 PM Bob
            you missed my point, Bob Sep 26 11 5:57 PM zambocello
               I was doing you a favor! Sep 26 11 7:48 PM Bob
   Not quite dead... Sep 26 11 11:28 AM cellokenno
   Abhorring certainty Sep 26 11 12:21 PM johntramsay
      . . . yet perpetuating it Sep 26 11 12:59 PM Bob
         "...As long as ..." Sep 26 11 4:26 PM zambocello
   Just curious---what's the longest thread in ICS history?! Sep 26 11 5:36 PM janjan
   What's a poor student of the cello to do? Sep 26 11 7:25 PM cellistpilot
      A student's objective Sep 28 11 7:57 AM Geemusic
         retired musician and computer programmer Sep 29 11 10:30 AM BobPrice
         Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 30 11 4:56 AM JFitzpatrick
            actually . . . Sep 30 11 6:04 AM Bob
            agreed JFitzpatrick Sep 30 11 9:20 PM Geemusic
   Wow, dgee is back! Sep 29 11 8:10 PM Matthew Tifford
      hey! Sep 30 11 3:51 AM Geemusic
   Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Sep 30 11 10:48 AM KeithHall
      Rostro 6th Sep 30 11 9:28 PM Geemusic
   A similar passage Oct 3 11 3:00 AM GeoffreyViolin
      Re: Bach Gigue #6 Question Oct 3 11 1:24 PM cellomaestro
      Geoffrey! Oct 4 11 2:10 PM rovatti
      Ok, I'm impressed, Geoffrey Oct 4 11 7:20 PM chiddler
   Umm, so did anybody mention the implied parallel 5th if A? Oct 5 11 6:16 AM chiddler
   This thread just needed to be resurrected May 14 12 11:13 AM ashcello93
      Allen Winold's Analysis of the Suites May 14 12 1:09 PM piaffe